How To Make Store Bought Cookies Look Homemade

Are you looking to impress your guests with homemade-looking cookies but don’t have the time or skills to bake from scratch? Fear not, because with a few simple tricks, you can easily make store bought cookies look like they came straight out of your own kitchen!

Firstly, adding personal touches is key. Whether it’s drizzling some melted chocolate over the top or sprinkling on some colorful candy pieces, customizing your store bought cookies will instantly elevate their appearance and make them seem more homemade.

Don’t be afraid to get creative and experiment with different flavors and decorations – this is where you can really show off your unique style and taste preferences.

So let’s dive into some easy tips and tricks for making store bought cookies look just as good (if not better) than homemade ones!

Add Personal Touches

You can easily elevate store-bought cookies by adding your own personal touches. For example, you could drizzle melted chocolate on top or sprinkle a bit of sea salt. These small additions make the cookies feel like they were made with love just for you.

Customizing the packaging is another great way to add a personal touch. Use cute boxes or bags and tie them with ribbon or twine. This creates the impression that you took the time to make something special.

To give your cookies a festive touch, add some sprinkles on top. You can find holiday-themed sprinkles at any baking supply store, or simply use colorful ones for a fun twist. Sprinkle them on top before serving or even package them in clear bags with the sprinkles on top for an extra pop of color.

These simple additions will not only make your store-bought cookies look homemade but also show how much thought and care you put into making them special.

Experiment with Flavors

Get creative with different flavor combinations to take your store-bought cookie hacks to the next level! Don’t be afraid to mix and match flavors or add in some unexpected ingredients.

For example, try adding a sprinkle of sea salt on top of your chocolate chip cookies for a sweet and salty twist. Or mix in some chopped nuts or dried fruit for added texture.

Another fun idea is to experiment with different extracts like almond or peppermint. Just a few drops can completely transform the flavor profile of your cookies.

And if you’re feeling really adventurous, try swapping out the oil or butter called for in the recipe with flavored varieties like coconut oil or browned butter. With these simple hacks, you’ll have everyone thinking your cookies are straight from grandma’s kitchen!

Play with Presentation

Transform your cookie creations into irresistible treats with a little bit of creativity and imagination in the way you present them. Just because you bought the cookies from a store doesn’t mean they can’t look homemade.

One easy way to do this is by creating DIY packaging for your cookies. You can buy small gift boxes or bags at a craft store, and then decorate them with stickers, ribbons, or even hand-drawn designs. This will give your cookies a personal touch that will make them stand out.

Another way to elevate your store-bought cookies is by playing with garnish options. Add some pizzazz to plain sugar cookies by sprinkling colored sugar on top before baking. Or, drizzle melted chocolate over chocolate chip cookies for an extra decadent touch. You can also try adding fresh fruit as a garnish on top of oatmeal or shortbread cookies for a healthy and refreshing twist.

Don’t be afraid to get creative with different combinations and flavors – it’s all about making your store-bought cookies look like something special!

Use Homemade Ingredients

To give your store-bought cookies an authentic homemade taste, try using homemade ingredients like freshly ground spices or handcrafted extracts. You can also create your own DIY baking mix that you can use for future batches of cookies. Using natural food coloring is another way to make your cookies look and taste homemade. You can experiment with different colors and shades to achieve the desired effect.

Aside from using homemade ingredients, you can also add a personal touch to your store-bought cookies by customizing the packaging and decorating them according to a specific theme. This will not only make them look more appealing but it’ll also give them a unique personality.

For example, you can wrap chocolate chip cookies in brown paper bags tied with twine for a rustic feel or decorate sugar cookies with royal icing in different shapes and colors for a festive occasion. With these simple tricks, you can easily transform store-bought cookies into homemade treats that are sure to impress anyone who tries them!

Get Creative with Shapes and Sizes

You can really add some personality to your treats by experimenting with different shapes and sizes. Instead of using the same old round cookie cutter, try a variety of shapes like hearts, stars, or animals. You can find cookie cutters in all sorts of designs at baking supply stores or even online.

Once you’ve got your cookies shaped, it’s time to get creative with decorating techniques. Use frosting, sprinkles, or even edible markers to add fun designs and messages to your cookies. A simple drizzle of melted chocolate or caramel can also elevate the look of your store-bought cookies.

With a little imagination and creativity, you’ll have homemade-looking treats that will impress anyone!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you use store-bought cookie dough to make homemade cookies?

Yes, you can use store-bought cookie dough to make homemade cookies. Add your own custom decorations or try some cookie dough hacks like adding extra ingredients for a unique twist on the classic recipe.

How can you make store-bought cookies taste fresher?

Want to add homemade flair to store bought treats? Here are some tips for refreshing store bought cookies: pop them in the oven for a few minutes, sprinkle with sea salt or drizzle with melted chocolate.

What are some creative ways to package store-bought cookies to give as gifts?

Looking for a fun and easy way to give store-bought cookies as gifts? Try DIY packaging! Use cute containers, ribbons, and customizable labels to make them look personalized and thoughtful.

Are there any homemade ingredients that can be used to enhance the flavor of store-bought cookies?

Elevate the flavor of store-bought cookies with spice mixtures like pumpkin pie or cinnamon sugar. For a healthier option, try frosting alternatives like almond butter or coconut cream. Enjoy homemade taste without the extra work!

How can you make store-bought cookies look fancier for special occasions?

Elevate store-bought cookies for special occasions with decorating techniques and garnish ideas. Add a drizzle of melted chocolate, sprinkle on colored sugar, or top with edible flowers. Impress your guests with these simple touches.


Congratulations! You’ve successfully learned how to make store-bought cookies look homemade.

Adding personal touches, experimenting with flavors, playing with presentation, using homemade ingredients, and getting creative with shapes and sizes are all great ways to elevate your cookies and impress your guests.

Remember that making store-bought cookies look homemade is not about disguising them or pretending that they were made from scratch. It’s about adding your own flair and personality to them while still appreciating the convenience of not having to bake from scratch.

So go ahead and have fun with it – let your creativity shine through and enjoy the delicious results!

Leave a Reply